A Recruiter Work Sample Without Personal Accounts
Run a recruiter work sample with fictional profiles, draft outreach and a shared rubric. See what to score and how to close the exercise.
Ernest Bursa
Give every applicant for your recruiter role the same fictional hiring brief and profiles. Ask them to shortlist two people, explain their choices and draft one outreach message for the reviewers. The exercise needs somewhere to submit the work. It can run without access to anyone’s personal accounts or a channel that sends messages to real prospects.
A Hacker News discussion began with an unverified account from an applicant who said their personal LinkedIn account was used after a recruiting trial.
A founder hiring their first recruiter wants to see how someone handles a vague brief, uneven evidence and a profile whose title makes it look stronger than it is. You can recreate those decisions on paper. The U.S. Office of Personnel Management describes work samples and simulations that mirror job tasks and let reviewers score what they observe or what the applicant produces.
Give the applicant a search with a real tradeoff
The following exercise is fictional. Put the brief and the cards in one document so everyone starts with the same evidence.
The role. A small software company needs an implementation engineer who can debug customer integrations and explain the issue to a customer with little technical background. The engineering lead would also like someone who has handled incidents on call. That experience is helpful for this search, and the lead can consider people without it. The hiring manager has asked to interview two people this week.
| Profile | Evidence in the packet |
|---|---|
| A | Built an integration that imports orders. Traced intermittent failures with logs and wrote a runbook for engineers. Customer contact is unclear. |
| B | Reproduced webhook failures with customers and wrote plain-language updates. Has never been on an on-call rotation. |
| C | Investigated payment issues as a support engineer and explained workarounds to customers. The profile does not show who made the code changes. |
| D | Has the exact job title and lists several integration tools. The only example describes rolling out an internal dashboard. |
| E | Led on-call response for failed data syncs and briefed engineering leadership. Customer-facing experience is unclear. |
| F | Onboards customers and writes integration guides. Escalates technical diagnosis to engineering. |
The instructions. Spend up to 45 minutes and submit a single document. Pick two profiles. For each, point to one detail that supports the choice and name one detail you would verify in a screening call. Draft a first message to one profile using only facts in the packet. Address it to the profile letter. The reviewers will read the draft in your submission. Nobody will send it.
In the debrief, give each applicant the same change to the brief. The role now requires on-call incident experience from day one. Ask which choice changes and why. Someone could move E onto the shortlist and still flag the gap in customer communication. Another person might keep a slot open until they can confirm A’s incident experience. Ask what evidence would settle the decision.
Score what the applicant can show
Agree on the scoring anchors before sending the exercise. Have reviewers score independently and cite a line from the submission or a specific debrief answer before discussing the applicant.
| Criterion | 1 point | 2 points | 3 points |
|---|---|---|---|
| Role calibration | Uses titles or keywords as the main reason for selection. | Identifies the core requirements but struggles to apply the changed brief. | Weighs essential and flexible criteria and explains what changes when on-call becomes essential. |
| Evidence and uncertainty | Asserts fit without pointing to the packet. | Cites evidence but leaves an important assumption unexamined. | Grounds each choice in the packet, names a material unknown and proposes a practical check. |
| Outreach judgment | Submits a generic draft or invents a claim about the profile or role. | Writes a clear note with a weak connection to the profile or an unclear next step. | Uses a specific profile detail, describes the opportunity accurately and makes a reasonable ask. |
The profile packet gives reviewers evidence about selection and writing. If the job also requires fluency with a particular search tool, add a supervised exercise with company-controlled access and synthetic data in an environment the provider permits. Disable delivery to real recipients. Reply rates and sustained pipeline management require other evidence.
Close the exercise when the work ends
Name a hiring-team owner before the invitation goes out. That person closes the exercise when the applicant submits, withdraws or reaches the deadline. The hiring decision can follow later.
For the document exercise, confirm that the submission reached the intended reviewers and keep it under your stated hiring retention policy. A colleague can run through the invitation first and verify that the only destination for the draft is the submission.
If you add a test tool, give the owner two places to check. In the system that grants access, verify that the temporary identity or connection can no longer reach the test environment. In the system that schedules actions, check for pending messages, invitations or other activity and cancel anything created by the exercise. Check what copies of the exercise data the tool still holds and handle those under the applicable policy.
LinkedIn’s developer documentation lists sign-in access and permission to post on a member’s behalf separately. LinkedIn also says that disconnecting a third-party app ends its future access to LinkedIn data, while the app owner may retain information it already received. If your exercise uses an external tool, verify access, scheduled actions and retained data where each is managed.
Run the file-based exercise in Kit
Start from Kit’s recruiter hiring template for the wider interview process. Use a Work Sample stage for this exercise. The applicant can start the task, read the private brief, upload their document and see a submission receipt. Set each criterion’s maximum score to 3. With assigned reviewers, use stage scoring criteria and review comments to record the evidence behind each score. Your hiring lead owns any closeout in a separate test tool.
Run the full exercise once with a colleague before inviting applicants. Check that they can explain a shortlist and draft a message using only the packet, then submit both for review.
Related articles
Try Kit for 30 days.
Hiring, security reports, and training in one account, for teams where none of it is a full-time job. Free for 30 days, card required. Cancel before it ends and you pay nothing.
Get started free